Review: A Few Good Men


Ellie Valdez, Dakota Muckelrath, and Joshua McGowen in A Few Good Men . Photo by Jared Blount.

By Larry Laneer
February 24, 2018

Who could’ve guessed playwright Aaron Sorkin would be so prescient in his 1989 play A Few Good Men? Or is it just that everyplace we look now, we see the grimy pawprints of Donald Trump?

A Few Good Men was one of Sorkin’s early successes. He went on to adapt the play for the 1992 film version and write the screenplay for The Social Network and create the television series The West Wing, among many other projects.

Real events inspired the play, now being staged by Pollard Theatre Company in Guthrie. It concerns the murder of a young Marine at the United States Navy base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. A court-martial drama, the play features all the charms and flaws of the genre. It can be compelling, but it includes that hoariest of courtroom-drama devices: the witness stand confession. Lawyers tell me that does not happen in real life.

Like much work today by playwrights who grew up on movies and television, the script is cinematic with many short scenes that leap miles between locations. (No worries; Shakespeare did the same thing.) This presents director Linda Lee McDonald with challenges, and she handles them efficiently. I was surprised at the end when I looked at my watch and saw the production runs two-and-a-half hours.

Joshua McGowen brings the right mix of acerbic wit and intelligence as the Navy lawyer defending two Marines who have been charged with murder. The character is a wiseacre who went to Harvard law school on a Navy scholarship. He seems to be biding his time while fulfilling his three-year obligation to the Navy handling minor cases, until this one.

Crystal Barby (solid, as usual) and Keegan Zimmerman give fine performances as the other defense lawyers. They are idealistic and committed to justice as much as they are to the Navy, as military lawyers should be.

Dakota Muckelrath and Ellie Valdez play the Marine defendants. The characters’ blindered devotion to “unit, Corps, God, country” makes you wonder if they’re expertly trained military professionals or victims of brainwashing.

The villain and source of the vileness that’s poisoned Gitmo is Lt. Col. Nathan Jessup, played convincingly (and surprisingly) by James A. Hughes. A longtime Pollard company member, Hughes may not be the first actor who comes to mind to play the Trumpian base commander. But insidiousness can take different forms, and as the play goes on, Hughes’s Jessup grows seamlessly credible. He is arrogant, demanding loyalty, and won’t hesitate to lie, cheat, and steal to get what he wants. Unlike Trump, Jessup appears to have genuine beliefs. When he says we live in a “world of walls” and he is the man on them defending America, he seems sincere in his own perverted way. To Jessup, the end justifies the means. Why wouldn’t it?

McDonald has assembled an able supporting cast. Alison Chambers seems young to be a military judge. Kevin Moore plays a Marine captain who has more integrity than a thousand Jessups.

Jerome Stevenson’s scenic design consists of four tiers painted institutional green with several wooden chairs and tables. The simple, flexible design helps McDonald keep the action moving.

The costumes (by Michael James) and how they are worn are mostly inauthentic. They are not ironed to military crispness; headgear isn’t worn when it should be; most footgear isn’t close to regulation. But military costumes are tricky. It isn’t against the law for costumes to be military uniforms, but the U.S. Code restricts the use of uniforms in films and plays. You can decide for yourself whether this production gets close enough. If you are military or a student of uniforms, you may be pleased or bothered by the costumes. If you’re neither, the costumes may seem fine.

Sorkin’s play shows what can happen when an entity (a military, government, or country) loses integrity and a sense of proportion. The characters talk a lot about honor while doing the most dishonorable deeds. That message remains completely relevant today.

A Few Good Men by Aaron Sorkin
Pollard Theatre Company
8:00 p.m. Fridays-Saturdays, through March 3
2:00 p.m. Sunday, February 18 and 25
8:00 p.m. Thursday, March 1
Pollard Theatre
120 W. Harrison, Guthrie